Main Photo Galleries
1

Ford's profits a byproduct of the auto bailout

Ford said Friday it made $13.4 billion in the fourth quarter, largely due to an accounting change. (AP / Ben Margot)
Ford said Friday it made $13.4 billion in the fourth quarter, largely due to an accounting change. (AP / Ben Margot)

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | Print Facebook   

Date: Saturday Jan. 28, 2012 9:04 AM ET

On Friday, we saw something of a miracle happen: Ford Motor reported a full-year pretax operating profit of $8.8 billion and full-year net income of $20.2 billion (all figures in U.S. dollars).

Ford's profits were the highest since 1998 thanks to a non-cash special item of $12.4 billion (I'll skip the accounting details on that).

Yes, we're talking about a miracle. Ford has engineered a phenomenal turnaround over the last half-dozen years. Remember, from 2006 to 2008 Ford lost $30.1 billion and borrowed $23 billion in late 2006 to fund a turnaround. Today, Ford's total automotive debt is at $13.1 billion, a drop of $6 billion in the last year.

Ford has money in the bank, too, and lots of it. As Automotive News reports, gross cash on hand is at $22.9 billion, with net cash at $9.8 billion, up from $1.4 billion a year earlier. Ford's financial position is strong and growing stronger.

That's why last month Ford's chief financial officer, Lewis Booth, told me he expects Ford to regain investment grade status this year. Ford has already reinstated its dividend after suspending it in 2006. "That will be a great day at Ford Motor Co.," said the taciturn Booth of regaining investment grade status.

Ford should be lauded for fixing itself without a full-blown government bailout. But let's not kid ourselves. Ford has had government help. For instance, Ford has taken advantage of $5.91 billion in cheap U.S. Department of Energy loans from the Advanced Technology Vehicle Manufacturing loan program. No. 2 on the loan list: Nissan North America at $1.45 billion, according to Automotive News.

It also seems clear that while Ford did not take a government bailout during the recent financial crisis that drove both General Motors and Chrysler into bankruptcy, Ford has benefited from direct government intervention in the automotive industry.

Paul Krugman, a Nobel Prize winner in economics who writes for The New York Times, explains why in his column today. He points out that successful companies like Ford Motor do not exist in isolation. "Prosperity depends on the synergy between companies, on the cluster, not the individual entrepreneur," he notes. This is pretty basic economic theory, by the way.

Now Krugman is an ardent progressive and his views are on the "left" of the political spectrum. But he does know economics; that Nobel Prize is evidence of that. In any case, he supports the bailouts of GM and Chrysler for sound economic reasons.

That is, while some have called the bailouts "crony capitalism," they're wrong. As Krugman points out, the bailouts of GM and Chrysler "rested crucially on the notion that the survival of any one firm in the industry depended on the survival of the broader industry 'ecology' created by the cluster of producers and suppliers in America's industrial heartland. If GM and Chrysler had been allowed to go under, they would probably have taken much of the supply chain with them - and Ford would have gone the same way."

Ford, as Krugman points out, would have failed if GM and Chrysler had been allowed to fail. The companies would all have been liquidated, and the supply chain around those companies would have been wiped out. The bailout worked and not just for GM and Chrysler, but also Ford.

We should all applaud the heroic efforts at Ford to reinvent itself and become phenomenally profitable, to pay off its debts and to rebuild its product lineup. But Ford's turnaround was not solely the product of management genius and worker commitment to excellence. It was not the product of a "heroic entrepreneur," although CEO Alan Mulally certainly has been a fantastic leader since he arrived in 2006 from Boeing.

As Krugman notes, "entrepreneurs need a supportive environment, and that sometimes government has to help create or sustain that supportive environment." Mulally and his leadership team are certainly business heroes, but the facts show that "it takes more than business heroes" to create a successful business and profitable industries as we're not seeing return to Detroit and its auto makers.

Let's cheer Ford's results, but I am sure that up on the 13th Floor of Ford World Headquarters in Dearborn, Mich., they are quietly acknowledging that without government bailouts of GM and Chrysler, Ford's turnaround would not have happened.

Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Autos.CTV.ca

Autos site

Latest news and columns

Click here to get the latest news, insights and info from the auto industry.

2012 Kia Rio

Jeremy Cato

Kia first in race for increased auto sales this year, Jeremy Cato writes.

Car designer Ferdinand Alexander Porsche is photographed 1963 with a Porsche 901 car  in 1990.  Ferdinand Alexander Porsche, the design chief credited with the classic 911 sports car and grandson of the automaker's founder, has died. (Porsche AG)

Michael Vaughan

The last Porsche to design a Porsche passes away

B-Max

Jeremy Cato

Have hybrids, electric cars killed the gas engine?

Geneva Motor Show

Geneva Motor Show

In Pictures: Va-va-vroom! Strange and classy models on display in Geneva.

High Performance

High Performance

In Pictures: From Lotus to Lamborghini, best sports cars from T.O. auto show.

Concept Cars

Concept Cars

In Pictures: Cool concept cars at the Canadian International Auto Show.

Auto Exotica

Auto Exotica

In Pictures: Supercars at the 2012 Canadian International Auto Show.

Most Talked about Stories

If there weren't so many people who hide their faces when committing violent acts then we wouldn't need a law forbidding masks. Unfortunately this is our society now. No one can hide their faces... we aren't special over here, violence has arrived and it is here to stay. Let's not kid ourselves. Violence just escalates to new levels. We've let this "hiding the faces" scenario go on far too long.

KC

Montreal bylaw could offer preview of federal mask ban